- Research article
- Open Access
Pesticidal and pest repellency activities of rhizomes of Drynaria quercifolia (J. Smith) against Tribolium castaneum (Herbst)
Biological Researchvolume 47, Article number: 51 (2014)
Tribolium castaneum (Herbst) is a harmful pest of stored grain and flour-based products in tropical and subtropical region. In the present study, rhizome of Drynaria quercifolia (J. Smith) was evaluated for pesticidal and pest repellency activities against T. castaneum, using surface film method and filter paper disc method, respectively. In addition, activity of the isolated compound 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid was evaluated against the pest.
Chloroform soluble fraction of ethanol extract of rhizome of D. quercifolia showed significant pesticidal activity at doses 0.88 to 1.77 mg/cm2 and significant pest repellency activity at doses 0.94 to 0.23 mg/cm2. No pesticidal and pest repellency activity was found for petroleum ether, ethyl acetate and methanol soluble fractions of ethanol extract as well as for 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid.
Considering our findings it can be concluded that chloroform soluble fraction of rhizome of D. quercifolia is useful in controlling T. castaneum of stored grain and flour-based products.
Pests/insects often cause extensive damage to stored grain products, which is a serious problem throughout the world . Certain pests can exist under a wide range of conditions and can attack products at all phases of storage and distribution. More than 2000 species of storage pests annually destroy approximately one third of the world’s food products. In many areas of the world, locally available materials are used to protect stored products against damage caused by pest infestation. Although synthetic pesticides are commonly used to control pests, is now causing concern because of environmental hazards, pests resistance and toxicity to mammals. Pesticides of plant origin, because of their high degree of tolerance by the mammals, are particularly desired for application against pests of fodders, fruits, vegetables and stored grains [2, 3]. The using of plant extracts in pest control has been practiced for at least two millennia, when botanical pesticides were considered important products for pest management in Ancient China, Egypt, India, Greece [4, 5]. Jacobson (1989) and Ketkar et al. (1976) have reviewed the effectiveness of plant derivatives for use against grain pests [6, 7]. In spite of the wide-spread recognition that many plants possess pesticidal properties, only a small number of pest control products directly obtained from plants [8, 9].
Tribolium castaneum (Herbst) is a major pest of stored flour and flour-based products in all tropical and subtropical countries of the world. Their presence in a stored food results in contamination and substantial economic damage due to loss of the products and a decrease in nutritional value. It is resistant to almost all organophosphorus pesticides. Dyte and Blackman (1972) reported that almost all of the strains of T. castaneum have become resistant to malathion . The occurrence of malathion resistance by different strains of T. castaneum has given an extra impetus to search for alternative way for the control of this pest. Drynaria quercifolia J. Smith (syn. Polypodium quercifolium, Fam. Polypodiaceae), locally known as Gurar, is a parasitic fern [11, 12] that is widely distributed in Bangladesh, India and Thailand [12, 13]. The present study was aimed to determine the pesticidal and pest repellency activities of rhizomes of D. quercifolia against T. castaneum. Moreover, an antibacterial compound 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid was isolated from the rhizome of the plant and its activity against T. castaneum was also evaluated.
In our experiment, at 24 h duration of exposure, chloroform soluble fraction of the plant was observed for significant pesticidal activity against T. castaneum (Table 1). With the increment of doses the mortality record was up-regulated i.e. highest mortality record (96.60%) was observed for dose 1.77 mg/cm2 and lowest mortality record (20.00%) was observed for the dose 0.22 mg/cm2 (Table 1, 2, Figure 1). LD50 of chloroform fraction for 24 h duration of exposure was 0.40 mg/cm2 (Table 2). When duration of exposure was increased (48 h), mortality record was little increased and LD50 little reduced 0.37 mg/cm2 (Table 2). No pesticidal activity was found for petroleum ether, ethyl acetate and methanol soluble fractions of the plant. The compound 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid that was isolated from ethyl acetate fraction (also detected in chloroform fraction) did not showed pesticidal activity against T. castaneum.
Pest repellency activity
In pest repellency study, chloroform fraction showed good repellency property at all tested doses (0.94 to 0.23 mg/cm2) (Table 3, Figure 2). Observations of first hours not significantly differ from the observations of subsequent hours (second, third, fourth and fifth hours). Like pesticidal activity, pest repellency activity also increased with doses. Petroleum ether, ethyl acetate and methanol soluble fractions as well as 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid were also subjected to pest repellency test, but no activity was found.
A wide range of stored food commodities including grain, flour, peas, beans, nuts, dried fruits and spices were affected by T. castaneum. A number of synthetic agents (e.g. methoprene, permethrin, cypermethrin, deltamethrin and fenvalerate etc) were identified for good activity against T. castaneum, however, use of these agents has led to problems such as environmental disturbances, increasing costs of application, pest resurgence, pest resistance to pesticides and lethal effects on non-target organisms, in addition to direct toxicity to users . To minimize use of synthetic pesticides and to avoid pollution of the environment, natural pesticide and repellent substances have been searched for pest control during recent times . Plant products having considerable pesticidal potential are gaining tremendous importance in recent years because such products minimize disadvantages associated with synthetic agents . Botanicals used as pesticides presently constitute about 1% of the world pesticide market .
Chloroform soluble fraction of D. quercifolia have both pesticidal and pest repellency activities against T. castaneum. High mortality rate was observed at higher doses (96.60% mortality at 1.77 mg/cm2 and 90.00% mortality at 0.88 mg/cm2) (Table 2, Figure 1). On the other hand, good pest repellency activity was observed even at lower doses (Table 3, Figure 2). Both pesticidal and pest repellency activities of chloroform soluble fraction of D. quercifolia are helpful in controlling pest (T. castaneum) of our stored food commodities. No pesticidal and pest repellency activities petroleum ether, ethyl acetate and methanol soluble fractions suggesting the compound(s) worked against T. castaneum present in chloroform soluble fraction. Although, 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid highly active against both gram positive and gram negative bacteria , no activity of the compound was found against T. castaneum, indicating some other compound(s) of chloroform soluble fraction were responsible for activity against the pest. Hence, further investigations should be done to isolate the pesticidal and pest repellent compound(s) from this chloroform soluble fraction as well as toxicological studies.
Among petroleum ether, ethyl acetate, chloroform and methanol soluble fractions of ethanol extract of rhizome of D. quercifolia, only the chloroform soluble fraction showed significant pesticidal activity against the pest. Furthermore, the fraction also showed significant pest repellency activity against the pest. Isolated compound 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid was inactive against the pest. Overall, it can be stated that good pesticidal and pest repellency activities of the rhizome of D. quercifolia suggesting its suitability as botanical pesticide in controlling T. castaneum of stored food commodities.
The fresh rhizomes of D. quercifolia J. Smith was collected in the month of October from mango trees of Khamar Bari, Lakshmidurpara, Lakshmipur, Bangladesh (year). The plant was taxonomically identified by Professor A. T. M. Naderuzzaman, Department of Botany, University of Rajshahi, Rajshahi, Bangladesh and its voucher specimen (No. 1939) had been deposited.
The rhizomes were first washed with water to remove adhering dirt, cut into small pieces, sun dried for three days and finally dried at 45°C for 36 h in an electrical oven . After complete drying, the entire portions were pulverized into a coarse powder with the help of a grinding machine (FFc-15, China) and were stored in an air tight container for further use .
Extraction of plant materials
The powder materials (600 g) were extracted with ethanol (3 L) in a Soxhlet apparatus (Quickfit, England). The extraction was continued for 72 h at 65°C. The extract was filtered through filter paper. The filtrate was concentrated under reduced pressure at 50°C in a rotary vacuum evaporator to afford a blackish green mass (52.4 g). The blackish green mass was further extracted with petroleum ether, chloroform, ethyl acetate and methanol, and dried under reduce pressure to afford petroleum ether (7.5 g), chloroform (7.8 g), ethyl acetate (5.5 g) and methanol (8.4 g) fractions, respectively .
Isolation of 3, 4-dihydroxy benzoic acid
The ethyl acetate soluble fraction was subjected to column chromatography using chloroform and methanol of increasing polarity. Column chromatography yielded 32 fractions. The fractions eluting with 10-25% methanol in chloroform were subjected to preparative TLC (mobile phase 15% methanol in chloroform) to give compound 1 (89 mg). In solubility test, compound 1 was sparingly soluble in water and freely soluble in ethyl acetate, methanol and acetone. The liquid chromatography/electrospray-mass spectroscopy (LC/ES-MS) in the positive ion mode of compound 1 showed molecular [M + H]+ peak at m/z 154.8 corresponding to a molecular formula of C7H6O4. The IR spectrum exhibited bands at 1240, 1375, 1739, 2877, 2908 and 2985 cm-1. The 1H-NMR, 13C-NMR, HSQC and HMBC spectral data of compound 1 was in good agreement with spectral data of 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid (Figure 3) published in literature .
Collection and maintenance of pest
The Tribolium species, T. castaneum (Herbst) used in the present experiment was originally received from the Crop Protection Department of the University of Newcastle, U.K. and were reared in the Crop Protection and Toxicology Laboratory, Department of Zoology, University of Rajshahi, Bangladesh.
T. castaneum were maintained in 1 L glass jar containing food medium. A filter paper was placed inside each jar for easy movement of the pest. The jar was covered with a filter paper at the top and kept in an incubator at 30 ± 0.5°C.
A standard mixture of wheat flour and powdered brewers yeast in the ratio of 19: 1 was used as food medium to culture the pest. Both flour and yeast were previously passed through a 250 micrometer aperture sieve and mixed thoroughly using an electric blender. The food was sterilized in an oven at 120°C for 6 h. Food was not used until at least 15 d after sterilization to allow its moisture content to equilibrate with that of environment.
Screening for pesticidal activity
Screening for pesticidal activity was carried out using surface film method [22–24], is a simple and widely used method. The working solution was prepared by dissolving 100 mg experimental sample in 2 ml mixed solvent (50% chloroform + 50% methanol) in a vial. For each sample similar three vials was prepared.
Thirteen clean and dried petridishes (size of each is 60 mm, area of each is 28.26 cm2) were taken for each sample. Four petridishes were marked by 50, 25, 12.5 and 6.25 mg. One ml working solution (prepared previously) was poured into the 50 mg petridish and agitated clockwise, anticlockwise, left to right and right to left to further confirm the uniform dispersion. One ml solvent (50% chloroform + 50% methanol) was added to that vial from which 1 ml had been used and mixed uniformly. From this vial, 1 ml solution was poured into the 25 mg petridish and agitated similarly for uniform dispersion. Using this serial dilution technique, likewise sample was poured into 12.5 mg and 6.25 mg petridishes and agitated similarly for uniform dispersion. The above processes were continued two times further using two remaining vials of working solution and eight remaining petridishes. Then the layers of dispersed sample into the petridishes were air dried. One ml solvent (50% chloroform + 50% methanol) was poured and dispersed into control petridish and air dried.
The pests were collected by sieving and ten pests were applied on each layer of dispersed sample into the petridish. This process is continued for each petridish. Then the number of pests have died were recorded after passing 24 and 48 h.
Pest Repellency Test
Pest repellency test was conducted using filter paper disc method [22, 24, 25]. The working solution was prepared by dissolving 60 mg experimental sample in 2 ml mixed solvent (50% chloroform + 50% methanol) in a vial. For each sample similar three vials was prepared.
Nine clean and dried petridishes (size of each is 90 mm) and Nine filter papers (size-90 mm) were taken for each sample. Three petridishes were marked by 30, 15 and 7.5 mg. Three filter papers were taken for these three petridishes and each filter paper was cut (by scissors) into equal two parts through centre where one part can be used as control part and other part can be used as treated part. For 30 mg petridish with its filter paper, treated part of filter paper was taken at outer background of the petridish and one ml working solution (prepared previously) was dispersed uniformly thorough out this part of filter paper and air dried. Then this part of filter paper was joined with its control part using transparent adhesive tape and placed into the 30 mg petridish using forceps. For 15 mg petridish with its filter paper, treated part of filter paper was taken at outer background of 15 mg petridish. One ml solvent (50% chloroform + 50% methanol) was added to that vial from which 1 ml had been used and mixed uniformly. From this vial, 1 ml solution was dispersed uniformly throughout the treated part of filter paper and air dried. Then this part of filter paper was joined with its control part using transparent adhesive tape and placed into the 15 mg petridish using forcep. Similar works was done for 7.5 mg petridish with its filter paper. The above processes were continued two times further using two remaining vials of working solution and six remaining petridishes and filter papers.
The pests were collected by sieving and ten pests were applied on the filter paper at the center of the petridish. This process was continued for each petridish. Then the number of pests have repelled were counted per hour interval up to 5 h. The percentages of repellency were determined and results were provided through ANOVA after transforming them into arcsin percentage value.
The percent mortality was subjected to statistical probit analysis  and the dose-mortality relationship was expressed as a median lethal dose (LD50). The repellency values in the recorded data were calculated for percent repellency, which was again transformed by arcsine transformation for the calculation of analysis of variances (ANOVA). Means values were compared using ANOVA (two factors without replication) (Additional File 1: Supplementary Table 1).
Upadhyay RK, Ahmad S: Management strategies for control of stored grain insect pests in farmer stores and public ware houses. World J Agric Sci 2011, 7: 527-549.
Blunt JW, Copp BR, Munro K, Northcote PT, Prinsep MR: Marine natural products. Nat Prod Rep 2005, 22: 15-61. 10.1039/b415080p
Adeyemi MMH: The potential of secondary metabolites in plant material as deterents against insect pests: A review. Afr J Pure Appl Che 2010, 4: 243-246.
Long Z, Hock S, Hung S: Screening of Chinese medicinal herbs for bioactivity against Sitophilus zeamais Motschulsky and Tribolium castaneum (Herbst). J Stored Prod Res 2006, 43: 290-296.
Isman MB: Botanical insecticides, deterrents, and repellents in modern agriculture and an increasingly regulated world. Annu Rev Entomol 2006, 51: 45-66. 10.1146/annurev.ento.51.110104.151146
Jacobson M: Botanical pesticide: past, present, and future. ACS Symposium Series No. 387. In Insecticides of Plant Origin. Edited by: Arnason JT, Philogene BJR, Morand P. Washington: American Chemical Society; 1989:1-10.
Ketkar CM, Kale GG, Tapkiri VB: Modified Neem Manorial Project. Neem Products Against Stored Gain Pests. 77: Directorate of Non-edible Oils and Soap Industry; 1976:76.
Isman MB: Neem and other botanical insecticides commercialization. Phytoparasitica 1997, 25: 339-344. 10.1007/BF02981099
Isman MB: Plant essential oils for pest and disease management. Crop Prot 2000, 19: 603-608. 10.1016/S0261-2194(00)00079-X
Dyte CF, Blackman DG: Laboratory evaluation of organophosphorus insecticides against susceptible and malathion-resistant strains of Tribolium castaneum (Herbst) (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae). J Stored Prod Res 1972, 8: 103-109. 10.1016/0022-474X(72)90027-6
Bhattacharya S: Chrinjib Banoushadi. 10th vol. 1st edition. Calcutta, India: Anand Publishing Ltd; 1990:223-226.
Khan A, Haque E, Rahman MM, Mosaddik A, Rahman M, Sultana N: Isolation of antibacterial constituent from rhizome of Drynaria quercifolia and its sub-acute toxicological studies. DARU 2007, 15: 205-211.
Kirtikar KR, Basu BD: Indian Medicinal Plants. 4th vol. 2nd edition. Dehra Dun, India: Dehra Dun Publisher Ltd; 1994:2745-2746.
Pugazhvendan SR, Elumalai K, Ross PR, Soundarajan M: Repellent activity of chosen plant species against Tribolium castaneum . World J Zool 2009, 4: 188-190.
Govindachari TR, Suresh G, Gopalakrishnan G, Wesley SD: Insect antifeedant and growth regulating activities of neem seed oil - the role of major tetranortriterpenoids. J Appl Entomol 2000, 124: 287-291. 10.1046/j.1439-0418.2000.00480.x
Pugazhvendan SR, Ross PR, Elumalai K: Insecticidal and repellant activities of plants oil against stored grain pest, Tribolium castaneum (Herbst) (Coleoptera:Tenebrionidae). Asian Paci J Trop Dis 2012, 2: S412-S415.
Rozman V, Kalinovic I, Korunic Z: Toxicity of natural occurring compounds of Lamiaceae and Lauraceae to three stored product insects. J Stored Prod Res 2007, 43: 349-355. 10.1016/j.jspr.2006.09.001
Khan A, Haque E, Rahman MM, Mosaddik A, Rahman M, Sultana N: A new triterpenoid from roots of Laportea crenulata and its antifungal activity. Nat Prod Res 2007, 21: 959-966. 10.1080/14786410701371470
Pandey N, Brave D: Antioxidant activity of ethanolic extract of Annona squamosa Linn Bark. Int J Biomed Pharmaceut Sci 2011, 2: 1692-1697.
Jeffery GH, Bassett J, Mendham J, Denney RC: Vogel’s Textbook of Quantitative Chemical Analysis. 5th ed. Harlow, England: Longman Group UK Ltd; 2000:161-162.
Lopa SS, Sadik G, Rahman MM, Islam R, Khondkar P, Alam AHMK, Rashid MA, Harun-or-Rasid: Oxoaporphinoids and a benzoic acid derivative from Cananga odorata . Dhaka Univ J Pharmaceuti Sci 2004, 3: 1-4.
Farhana K, Islam H, Emran EH, Islam N: Toxicity and repellant activity of three spice materials on Tribolium castaneum (herbst) adults. J Bio-sci 2006, 14: 127-130.
Mostafa M, Hossain H, Hossain MA, Biswas PK, Hague MZ: Insecticidal activity of plant extracts against Tribolium castaneum Herbst. J Adv Sci Res 2012, 3: 80-84.
Iram N, Arshad M, Akhter N: Evaluation of botanical and synthetic insecticide for the control of Tribolium castaneum (Herbst) (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae). BioAssay 2013, 8: 1-10.
Mondal OA, Haque J, Haque E, Khan AR: Repellent activity of Abroma augusta extracts against Tribolium castaneum (herbst) adults. J Bio-Sci 2012, 20: 49-55.
Busvine J: A Critical Review of the Techniques for Testing Insecticides. London: Commonwealth Agricultural Bureau; 1971:345-346.
The authors wish to thank Professor A.T.M. Naderuzzaman, Department of Botany, University of Rajshahi, Rajshahi, Bangladesh for identification the plant and the Chairman, Department of Pharmacy, University of Rajshahi, Rajshahi, Bangladesh for funding for the research.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
AK was responsible for conducting the experiments, data analysis and manuscript preparation. MEI, MAAA and MAS supported AK in phytochemical investigation, whereas MHI and MSP supported AK in biological activity investigation. MNI supervised biological works and MEH supervised phytochemical works. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.