- Research article
- Open Access
Essential oils from two Eucalyptus from Tunisia and their insecticidal action on Orgyia trigotephras (Lepidotera, Lymantriidae)
Biological Researchvolume 47, Article number: 29 (2014)
Essential oils extracted from aromatic and medicinal plants have many biological properties and are therefore an alternative to the use of synthetic products. The chemical composition of essential oils from two medicinal plants (Eucalyptus globulus and E. lehmannii) was determined and, their insecticidal effects on the third and fourth larval stages of Orgyia trigotephras were assessed.
Larvae were collected from Jebel Abderrahmane (North-East of Tunisia), conserved in groups of 50/box (21 × 10 × 10 cm) at a temperature of 25°C. Larvae were tested for larvicidal activities of essential oils. Each oil was diluted in ethanol (96%) to prepare 3 test solutions (S1 = 0.05%, S2 = 0.10% and S3 = 0.50%). Essential oils were used for contact, ingestion and Olfactory actions and compared to reference products (Bacillus thuringiensis and Decis). Olfactory action of essential oils shows that larvae mortality is higher than contact action, lower than ingestion action. MTM and FTM of S3 of E. lehmannii were respectively 1 h 32 min and 1 h 39 min are higher than those of E. globulus (MTM = 51 min and FTM = 1 h 22 min 34 sec). Contact action of E. lehmannii oil shows low insecticidal activity compared to E. globulus. MTM are respectively (1 min 52 sec and 1 min 7 sec), FTM are (2 min 38 sec, 1 min 39 sec), are the shortest recorded for S3, on the third stage of larvae. The fourth stage of larvae, MTM are (2 min 20 sec and 2 min 9 sec), FTM are (3 min 25 sec, 3 min 19 sec). Ingestion action of essential oils is longer than the contact action, since the time of death exceeds 60 minutes for all species.
Results shows that essential oils have a toxic action on nerves leading to a disruption of vital system of insects. High toxic properties make these plant-derived compounds suitable for incorporation in integrated pest management programs.
Acquired resistance and environmental pollution due to repeated applications of persistent synthetic insecticides have created interest in discovering new natural insecticide products . The use of plants with insecticidal activity has several advantages over the use of synthetic products, natural insecticides are obtained from renewable resources and quickly degradable, the development of insect resistance to these substances is slow, the substances do not leave residues in the environment, they are easily obtained by farmers and they cost less to produce . The effects of essential oils on insects have been the subject of several studies. These oils are formed by a complex mixture of volatile constituents originating from the secondary metabolism of plants and are characterized by a strong scent . The components in essential oils vary not only with plant species but also in relation to climate, soil composition, part of the plant and age of the plant. Since many trees were damaged by insects, the search for insecticides and repellents of botanical origin has been driven by the need to find new products that are effective, furthermore safer and cheaper than current products . Additionally, people prefer natural products than synthetics . Many secondary plant metabolites are known for their insecticidal properties, and in many cases plants have a history of use as home remedies to kill or repel insects . In recent decades, research on the interactions between plants and insects has revealed the potential use of plant metabolites or allelochemicals for this purpose . It is known that some chemical constituents of essential oils have insecticidal properties . In some studies, essential oils obtained from commercial sources were used. Specific compounds isolated from plant extracts or essential oils were tested for fumigation purposes .
Among essential oils, Eucalyptus oil, in particular, is more useful as it is easily extractable commercially (industrial value) and possesses a wide range of desirable properties worth exploiting for pest management [10, 11]. Previous studies reported the fumigant toxicity of essential oils from various Eucalyptus species against different developmental stages ; furthermore the presence of volatile monoterpenes provides an important defense strategy to the plants, particularly against herbivorous insect pests and pathogenic fungi .
This study aims to evaluate toxic activities of essential oils obtained from two Eucalyptus species: Eucalyptus lehmannii and Eucalyptus globulus against third and fourth larval stage of Orgyia trigotephras.
Essential oils composition
Essential oils efficiency from E. globulus and E. lehmannii leaves is above 1%. R = 1.25% for E. globulus and R = 1.05% for E. lehmannii.
As for essential identification, GC and GC/MS analysis of E. globulus and E. lehmannii essential oils led to the identification of 32 compounds. The E. globulus essential oil profile is characterized by α-pinene (13.61%) and 1.8-cineole (43.18%) as major compounds. Furthermore, E. lehmannii is characterized by 1.8-cineole (50.20%) and α-pinene (18.71%) as major compounds. Among other components, the majority belongs to sesquiterpenoïd hydrocarbon volatile compounds (Table 1).
The evaluation of the contact action of essential oils on larvae of O. trigotephras showed a similar effect for the two tested oils. For all concentrations, the MTM and the FTM of larvae treated with essential oils were very short compared to the time of death of larvae treated with Decis.
Ethanol used as a solvent for essential oils, produce no toxic effect on larvae. Oils are revealed to be highly toxic on the third instar larvae. The MTM and FTM are the shortest recorded for a concentration of 0.5 ml. However, E. lehmannii oil shows low insecticidal activity compared to the oil of E. globulus.
Third instar larvae treated by E. lehmannii present a MTM = 11 min 22 sec and FTM = 16 min 55 sec, higher than E. globulus (MTM = 2 min and FTM = 5 min 20 sec) for S1 = 0.05%. MTM and FTM, obtained after treatment with 0.5% of E. lehmannii were respectively 1 min 52 sec and 2 min 38 sec are higher than those of E. globulus (with MTM = 1 min 7 sec and FTM = 1 min 39 sec) (Figure 1).
Fourth instar larvae treated by E. lehmannii present a MTM = 40 min and FTM = 54 min 49 sec, higher than E. globulus (MTM = 16 min 49 sec min and FTM = 32 min) for S1 = 0.05%. MTM and FTM, obtained after treatment with 0.5 ml of E. lehmannii were respectively 2 min 20 sec and 3 min 25 sec are higher than those of E. globulus (with MTM = 2 min 9 sec and FTM = 3 min 19 sec) (Figure 2).
Ingestion action of essential oils is longer than the contact action, since the time of death exceeds 60 minutes for all species. E. globules present the best insecticidal effect. Toxicity of E. globulus observed for 3 tested concentrations was particularly important when the concentration is high (S3). MTM = 1 h 40 min and FTM = 3 h 4 min for the third instar larvae and MTM = 1 h 37 min and FTM = 3 h 3 min (Figures 3 and 4).
Thus, it is necessary to do insect histology after treatment with oils to detect tissue target and to identify alteration type. Moreover, essential oils can cause cytoplasm coagulation, damage lipids and proteins or cause cell lysis . A similar phenomenon was observed with B. thurengiensis treatment.
As for olfactory action, the third stage of larvae of O. trigotephras treated by E. lehmannii present a TMM = 4 h 1 min and TFM = 8 h 2 min, higher than E. globulus (MTM = 1 h 10 min and FTM = 2 h 11 min) for S1 = 0.05%. MTM and FTM, obtained after treatment with 0.5 ml of E. lehmannii were respectively 1 h 32 min and 1 h 39 min are higher than those of E. globulus (with MTM = 51 min and FTM = 1 h 22 min 34 sec) (Figure 5).
The fourth stage of larvae of O. trigotephras treated by E. lehmannii present a MTM = 1 h 40 min and FTM = 2 h 33 min, higher than E. globulus (MTM = 48 min min and FTM = 1 h 56 min) for S1 = 0.05%. MTM and FTM, obtained after treatment with 0.5 ml of E. lehmannii were respectively 1 h 50 min and 2 h 54 min are higher than those of E. globulus (with MTM = 35 min and FTM = 1 h 2 min) (Figure 6).
Olfactory action of essential oils shows that larvae mortality is higher than contact action, lower than ingestion action. MTM and FTM of E. lehmannii are lowest for S3. Larvae mortality is highest for S1 and S2 (Figures 5 and 6). Ingestion action is more effective and contact action is the less effective. It seems that contact action reduce processing times. However, the ingestion action is the most solicit because it indicates the specificity of the product to the insect. Although, more the necessary time for insect mortality is long, it is sure that the product will be toxic to the pest.
Contact action of essential oils is comparable to chemical insecticide that affects the nervous system of larvae as cited by Enan  and Cetin et al. . Essential oils have a toxic action on nerves leading to a disruption of vital system of insects [14, 15]. However the highest MTM and FTM of Decis compared to essential oils may be attributed to the limited distribution on the body of larvae unlike essential oils that spread quickly and easily on the back of the insect. The variations between death times resulted from the change in percentages of essential oils components as elucidated by Aslan et al. . The toxicity of certain compounds of essential oils on the fourth instars larvae of Thaumetopoea pityocampa has been carried out by Kanat and Alma , he showed that turpentine of Pinus brutia had the best insecticidal activity (MTM = 0.51 min) due to camphene presence. Kanat and Alma  revealed that essential oils of Thymus vulgaris composed by carvacrol, p-cymene; thymol and Juniperus communis composed by camphene and α-pinene have a better insecticide effect than Lavandula angustifolia composed by linalool acetate, linalyl, 1,8-cineole and borneol.
Cymbopogon citratus, Lippia sidoides, Ocimum americanum and Ocimum gratissimum essential oils showed good insecticidal activity against Aedes aegypti. Constituents of these oils are the monoterpenoids geranial: citral for C. citratus, thymol for L. sidoides, E-methylcinnamate for O. americanum and eugenol, 1,8-cineole for O. gratissimum. Myroxylum balsamum essential oil presented good larvicidal activity against A. aegypti larvae, the monoterpenes α-pinene and β-pinene were the main constituents . All these constituents are similar as E. lehmannii and E. globules essential oils.
Treatment with Bacillus thurengiensis is long since the action occurs after being gulped, release of toxin and its binding to specific receptors in the midgut of the insect. Ingestion action of E. globulus and E. lehmannii oils is faster for S1 for the third instar larvae (MTM = 5 h 3 min and FTM = 8 h 33 min) and for the fourth instar larvae (MTM = 5 h 37 min and FTM = 23 h 8 min), than B. thurengiensis (MTM = 1j 34 h 57 sec, FTM = 1j 42 h 3 min for the 3rd instar larvae and MTM = 1j 25 h 17 min, FTM = 1j 41 h 14 min for the 4th instar). It is well known that the biopesticide B. thurengiensis acts only by ingestion. This bacterium may have a different effect due to the diversity of toxins that can produce .
Previous study on monoterpenes’ action on third instar larvae of Anisakis simplex Aslan et al.  showed that carvacrol was responsible for cells lysis, alteration of the membrane and perforation of the medgut. Essential oil composition varies not only with plant species but also in relation to climate, soil composition, part of the plant and age of the plant . These substances are usually volatile and can be detected by the antennae or tarses of insects. The great majority of the literature on the terpenoids effects on insects has reported growth inhibition, impaired maturation, reduced reproductive capacity, appetite suppression and death of predator insects by starvation or direct toxicity . Monoterpene limonene demonstrated insecticidal activity by penetrating the cuticle of the insect “contact effect”, by respiration “fumigant effect” and through the digestive system “ingestion effect” .
Our results clearly demonstrated a high toxic effectiveness relatively to B. thurengiensis treatment (ingestion action) and Decis treatement (fumigant and contact action) against both larval phases of this pest.
To conclude, our study showed that E. globulus and E. lehmannii essential oils compositions were characterized by the presence of 1.8-cineole (43.18%; 50.20%), α-pinene (13.61%; 18.71%) respectively as major compounds. It is clear that essential oils from Eucalyptus spp are rich of monoterpenoid, compounds that possess insecticidal activity against various insect species. High larvicidal properties make derived compounds suitable for incorporation of integrated pest management program. These results show that application of natural plant products as E. lehmannii and E. globules which have a toxic effect against larvae of Orgyia trigotephras can be a potential method in environmental- friendly control management.
Plant material and larvae collect
Our study was carried out in the arboretum of Jebel Abderrahmaen (North-east of Tunisia). Four branches from the quadrant (N, S, E and W) were cut off from five trees of the two Eucalyptus species; E. lehmannii and E. globules using a telescopic tree pruner. Branches were separately placed in plastic bags. In the lab, leaves were carried out and air-dried at room temperature (20-25°C) for one week and stored for essential oil extraction. Larvae were collected from Jebel Abderrahmane, conserved in groups of 50 per box (21 × 10 × 10 cm) at a temperature of 25°C and fed every two days on fresh leaves of Erica multiflora Third and fourth stage larvae of Orgyia trigotephras were tested for larvicidal activities of essential oils.
Essential oil extraction and volatile compounds identification
100 g of dry matter of leaves were used for Essential oils extraction by hydro-distillation method during 90 min using a modified Clevenger-type apparatus. Anhydrous sodium sulphate was used to remove water after extraction. The extracted oils were stored in Eppendorf safe-lock tubes and stored at −4°C.
Essential oils were analyzed by gas chromatography (GC) using a Hewlett-Packard 6890 gas chromatograph (Agilent Technologies, Palo Alto, California, USA) equipped with a flame ionization detector (FID) and an electronic pressure control (EPC) injector. A polar HP-Innowax (PEG) column (30 m × 0.25 mm, 0.25 mm film thickness) and an apolar HP-5 column (30 m × 0.25 mm coated with 5% phenyl methyl silicone, and 95% dimethyl polysiloxane, 0.25 mm film thickness) from Agilent were used. Carrier gas flow (N2) was 1.6 ml/min and the split ratio 60:1. Analyses were performed using the following temperature program: oven kept isothermally at 35°C for 10 min, increased from 35 to 205°C at the rate of 3°C/min and kept isothermally at 205°C for 10 min. Injector and detector of temperatures were held, respectively, at 250 and 300°C. The GC/MS analyses were made using an HP-5972 mass spectrometer with electron impact ionization (70 eV) coupled with an HP-5890 series II gas chromatograph. An HP-5MS capillary column (30 m × 0.25 mm coated with 5% phenyl methyl silicone, and 95% dimethyl polysiloxane, 0.25 μm film thicknesses) was used. The oven temperature was programmed to rise from 50 to 240°C at a rate of 5°C/min. The transfer line temperature was 250°C. Helium was used as carrier gas with a flow rate of 1.2 ml/min and a split ratio of 60:1. Scan time and mass range were 1 s and 40e300 m/z respectively.
Essential oil volatile compounds were identified by calculating their retention index (RI) relative to (C9-C18) n-alkanes (Analytical reagents, Labscan, Ltd, Dublin, Ireland) and data for authentic compounds available in the literature and in our data bank, and also by matching their mass spectrum fragmentation patterns with corresponding data stored in the mass spectra library of the GC-MS data system (NIST) and other published mass spectra . The relative percentage amount of each identified compound was obtained from the electronic integration of its FID peak area.
Essential oils efficiency
Essential oils efficiency (R) is expressed by the ratio between the amount of oil extracted and the amount of plant material used for extraction. R (%) = (mass of the essential oil obtained per mass of plant material used)*100.
Preparation of test solutions and chemical insecticide
Each oil was diluted in ethanol (96%) to prepare 3 test solutions (S1 = 0.05%, S2 = 0.10% and S3 = 0.50%). The essential oils were tested by contact action, ingestion action and olfactory action. The larvicidal effect of essential oils by contact is appreciated by comparison to a chemical insecticide Delta-metrine “Decis” (Atlas Agro-Tunisia). Ethanol used for dilutions was already used as control. The larvicidal effect by ingestion of essential oils is assessed by comparison to a biological insecticide Bacillus thuringiensis (reference product, provided by Atlas Agro-Tunisia).
Ten larvae were placed in Petri dishes (R = 9 cm). This experiment was replicated 6 times for each test. The rest of the larvae were placed in plastic boxes.
Contact and ingestion action of essential oils
Firstly, 10 μl of each oil solution prepared was deposited on the back of each larva; a total of 60 larvae from 3rd and 4th stage were used and secondary 100 μl from each oil concentration are spread over Erica multiflora leaves. Leaves are left in open air until total absorption, than are placed in Petri dishes with 10 fasted larvae to test ingestion action.
Residual toxicity test and evaluation of the insecticidal
100 μl of each test solution were deposited on the bottom of Petri dishes (R = 9 cm) and dried for 20 min at 21°C, 10 larvae per replication were placed to test olfactory action.
The larvicidal activity of essential oils, reference products (Bacillus thuringiensis, Decis) and ethanol were determined by measuring the average time of mortality rate (MTM) corresponding to the time required to kill 50% of larvae and the final time of mortality (FTM) corresponding to the death of the total larvae.
The statistical treatment of data is performed using SPSS (Version 10.0). MTM and FTM were analyzed for variance by the Fisher test to test the hypothesis of equality of means at the threshold 5%. It is complemented by multiple comparisons of means by the LSD test (Least Significant Difference).
Viegas-Junior C: Terpenos com atividade inseticida: uma alternativa para o controle quı’mico de insetos. Quim Nova 2003, 26: 390-400. 10.1590/S0100-40422003000300017
Roel AR: Utilização de plantas com propriedades inseticidas: uma contribuição para o Desenvolvimento Rural Sustentável. Revista Internacional do Desenvolvimento Local 2001, 1: 43-50.
Bakkali F, Averbeck S, Averbeck D, Idaomar M: Biological effects of essentials oils- a review. Food Chem Toxicol 2008, 46: 446-475. 10.1016/j.fct.2007.09.106
de Paula JP, Farago PV, Checchia LEM, Hirose KM, Ribas JLC: Atividade repelente do oleo essencial de Ocimum selloi Benth (variedade eugenol) contra o Anopheles braziliensis Chagas. Acta Farm Bonaer 2004, 23: 376-378.
Yaghoobi-Ershadi MR, Akhavan AA, Jahanifard E, Vantandoost H, Amin GH, Moosavi L, Ramazani ARZ, Abdoli H, Arandian MH: Repellency effect of Myrtle essential oil and DEET against Phlebotomus papatasi , under laboratory conditions Iranian. J Public Health 2006, 35: 7-13.
Broussalis AM, Ferraro GE, Martino VS, Pinzon R, Coussio JD, Alvarez JC: Argentine plants as potential source of insecticidal compounds. J Ethnopharmacol 1999, 67: 219-223. 10.1016/S0378-8741(98)00216-5
Pavela R: Insecticidal activity of some essential oils against larvae of Spodoptera littoralis . Fitoterapia 2005, 76: 691-696. 10.1016/j.fitote.2005.06.001
Spitzer C: Oleos volateis. In Farmacognosia: da planta ao medicamento Porto Alegre Edited by: Simoes CMO, Schenkel EP, Gosmann G, Mello JCP, Mentz LA, Petrovick PR. 2004, 467-495.
Rajendran S, Sriranjini V: Plant products as fumigants for stored productinsect control. J Stored Prod Res 2008, 44: 126-135. 10.1016/j.jspr.2007.08.003
Boland DJ, Brophy JJ, HOUSE, A.P.N (Eds): Eucalyptus Leaf Oils. Use, Chemistry, Distillation and Marketing. Melbourne/Sydney: Inkata Press; 1991.
Barton AFM: The oil mallee project, a multifaceted industrial ecology case study. J Ind Ecol 2000, 3: 161-176.
Ben Jemâa JM, Haouel S, Bouaziz M, Khouja ML: Seasonal variations in chemical composition and fumigant activity of five Eucalyptus essential oils against three moth pests of stored dates in Tunisia. J Stored Prod Res 2012, 48: 61-67.
Langenheim JH: Higher plant terpenoids: a phytocentric overview of their ecological roles. J Chem Ecol 1994, 20: 1223-1280. 10.1007/BF02059809
Enan E: Insecticidal activity of essential oils: octopaminergic sites of action. Comp Biochem Physiol 2001, 130: 325-337.
Cetin H, Erler F, Yanikoglu A: Toxicity of essential oils extracted from Origanum onites L and Citrus aurentium L against the pine processionary moth, Thaumetopoea wilkinsoni Tams . Folia Biol 2006, 54: 153-157. 10.3409/173491606778557473
Aslan I, Özbek H, Çalma Ö, Fikrettin S: Toxicity of essential oil vapours to two greenhouse pests, Tetranychus urticae Koch and Bemisia tabaci Genn. Industrial Crops and Products. 2004, 19: 167-173. 10.1016/j.indcrop.2003.09.003
Simas NK, Lima EC, Conceição SR, Kuster RM, Oliveira Filho AM: Produtos naturais para o controle da transmissao da dengue– atividade larvicida de Myroxylon balsamum (oleo vermelho) e de terpenoides e fenilpropanoides. Quim Nova 2004, 27: 46-49.
Kanat M, Alma MH: Insecticidal effects of essential oils from various plants against larvae of pine processionary moth ( Thaumetopoea pityocampa Schiff) (Lepidoptera: Thaumetopoeidae ) . Pest Manag Sci 2003, 60: 173-177.
Cavalcante GM, Moreira AFC, Vasconcelos SD: Potencialidade inseticida de extratos aquosos de essências florestais sobre moscabranca. Presquisa Agropecuària Brasileira 2006, 41: 9-14.
Raussel C, Martinez-Ramirez AC, Garcia-Robles I, Real MD: The toxicity and physiological effects of Bacillus thuringiensis toxins and formulations on Thaumetopoea pityocampa , the pine processionary caterpillar. Pestic Biochem Physiol 1999, 65: 44-54. 10.1006/pest.1999.2426
Prates HT, Santos JP, Waquil JM, Fabris JD, Oliveira AB, Foster JE: Insecticidal activity of monoterpenes against Ryzopertha dominica (F) and Tribolium castaneum (Herbst). J Stored Prod Res 1998, 34: 243-249. 10.1016/S0022-474X(98)00005-8
Adams RP: Identification of Essential Oil Components by Gas Chromatography/Quadrupole Mass Spectroscopy Allured. USA: Carol Stream II; 2001.
Authors are grateful to Mohamed Laarbi KHOUJA, to Henia CHOGRANI for their help and to the “Institut National de Recherches en Génie Rural, Eaux et Forêts” (Tunisia) for providing assistance to undertake this work.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
BB and OE contributed equally to the realization of this work. SD and MB supervised this scientific study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Badreddine Ben Slimane, Olfa Ezzine contributed equally to this work.